Friday, October 12, 2012

Canada was built on the spirit of northern flying . . .


Safety then as now was a concern.  

Entrepreneurial spirit, determination and just plain guts were words associated with the development of air service in Canada’s north. Names like Wop May, Punch Dickins, George Gorman, Max Ward, William Munroe Archibald, John Austin and Harry Kennedy among others bring to mind developing and pioneering air service to otherwise poorly accessible regions of this vast nation. For a large portion of this country, air service is still by and large their primary means for service and connection with the rest of the country and world. For many communities everything from mail through to food, water, fuel, medical supplies and even manufacturing support and people is delivered or moved point to point by some sort of air service.

Start with a look back . . .


By the 1960s and early 70s, remote flying was an established and growing service but still somewhat rustic in comparison to today. Jim Morrison is well known to many in the aviation world. While today he is the Managing Director of Toronto based Partner Jet Inc., Jim is one of the guys who earned his way up the aviation ladder through a succession of jobs – starting with flying on the unimproved, underserviced and high demand routes of the day in the North. “I spent the very first years of my career working for Russ Bradley at Bradley Air Services based in Carp Ontario” says Morrison.  After flying aerial survey on Beech 18s, Aero Commanders and DC3’s across North and South America and Africa, Jim headed to Northern Quebec and flew first for Survair and then Air Inuit. “We ran a scheduled charter service in those days with Twin Otters , DC3 and Canso aircraft. The scheduled flights happened 6 days a week typically. The run started in Fort Chimo (Kuujuac now) covered Payne Bay Koartak, Wakenham Bay and Sugluc with stops in Leaf Bay and Aupaluk. All of these communities have new names now. The airstrips in the 70s were anywhere from 800’ to 1200’, gravel with only NBD approaches and limited weather information along the coast. We would fly the schedule with either the Twin Otter or the DC3 and be on call for medevacs through the nights.

Cargo work was steady too. The freight loads needed to be moved as well as the mail and fresh groceries. Charters came up on a regular basis and medevacs happened at least 4 or 5 times a week mostly late a night and often in inclement weather - which added to the excitement. I volunteered for many of the medevac trips as it broke the boredom of the staff house.”

“Turn over was high. Pilots typically flew in the north to build hours and move on to the airlines. The average age of pilots up north then was roughly 35 and the majority were in their mid 20s as I was.  For training, we did an in house course on the Twin Otters, DC3s but the HS748s were done at Eastern Provincial Airways (EPA). EPA was the first formal training I saw in the early years and it was exceptional. There was no pressure put on pilots to perform but it was very competitive in those days. There was a lot of pride in completing flights and getting the job done. Each pilot had his or her own set of limitations and stayed within them carefully. The accidents we saw while flying up there and there were a few, mainly were the result of inexperience or lack of cockpit resource management.”

And today . . .


In speaking with pilots and operators today it seems that while the flying hardware has changed, the runways may now be a bit longer and overall the flight ops are supported by broader reaching nav aids, but the basic work and sort of operators along with the people they attract to their jobs is by and large unchanged. Some northern operators have, at their own expense, implemented on-site improvements at some strips including lighting and radios – complete with a locally trained resident to operate and provide real time observations of local conditions.

Technology on the other hand is the one area where there has been a dramatic shift – and one that affords operators a new level of insight and resulting safety as they try their best to support the vast outlying regions of this country. The introduction of new avionics technologies has allowed for a vastly improved level of safety in these operational models. The problem is that while the technology is available, many operators have elected not to introduce or incorporate these options. But all that could be about to change.

The flight into terrain incident involving Keystone Air at Spirit Lake in January of this year was the third incident for the airline since 2000 and the second involving fatalities. And they are not alone. This was in fact the latest in a rash of incidents over the last few years involving smaller airlines that are by all rights hard working and provide invaluable and much needed service into remote communities. These incidents have raised the question of training and the use – or lack of – modern nav aids in the types of aircraft typically used in this sort of operation. What the Spirit Lake incident has brought into the spotlight are a series of issues related to single pilot commercial operations, the challenges of working from unimproved local airstrips and the use of newer technology in the cockpit to aid pilot operations. The use and application of SMS has also been questioned.
Transport Canada was already in the process of changing some of the requirements related to aircraft that are most commonly used in this sort of flight operation. What Spirit Lake and other incidents over the last year did was simply bring the attention of many to an issue that has been smoldering for quite some time. Ask anyone in the avionics world and they will state with certainty that 2012 will be the year that things change. Transport Canada has published Advisory Circular AC 600-003 for Terrain Awareness Warning System (TAWS) regulations. As they report, from 1977 to 2009, 35 airworthy aeroplanes were flown into the ground while under pilot control. Known as controlled flight into terrain (CFIT) accidents, the reported numbers show 100 fatalities and 46 serious injuries as a result of these CFITs. As TC state “To date, risk information alone has not motivated all of the Canadian aviation industry to voluntarily equip key passenger aircraft with existing technologies that would help mitigate risks associated to CFITs.”

The current proposed regulatory amendment (as of writing this article) will introduce requirements for the installation of Terrain Awareness Warning Systems (TAWS) equipped with an Enhanced Altitude Accuracy (EAA) function in private turbine-powered aeroplanes configured with six or more passenger seats, excluding pilot seats, and in commercial aeroplanes configured with six or more passenger seats, excluding pilot seats. The Gazette from TC goes on to state that operators would have two years from the date on which the Regulations come into force to equip their aeroplanes with TAWS and five years to equip with EAA. Norm Matheis, Universal Avionics’ regional manager for Canada feels that  “This is positive change in real terms in safety of flight for remote operations. Our top Canadian Universal dealers are seeing an upswing in hangar bookings now for TAWS mods, in anticipation of the publishing of the TAWS rule in Canada Gazette II this year”.

A TAWS Class A system provides the highest level of protection. It will be required in Commuter CAR 704 Aeroplanes configured with 10 or more passenger seats, excluding pilot seats, and in all aeroplanes operating under subpart 705 for airline operations.

The Class B system has less capability and will be required for private turbine-powered aeroplanes configured with 6 or more seats, excluding pilot and co-pilot. It will also be mandatory on all commercial subpart 703 air taxi aeroplanes configured with 6 or more passenger seats, as well as Commuter subpart 704 Aeroplanes configured with 6 to nine passenger seats, excluding pilot and co-pilot.

Norm Matheis, Regional Marketing Manager – Canada – with Universal Avionics Systems has a lot of experience in helping with northern flight ops. His firm have been pioneers in the WAAS system introduction and implementation of numerous aircraft in this country. In looking at northern flight op safety as a whole, Matheis says: “Today we still see some air operators in the north operating without CFIT protection apart from their flight crew using MK I eyeball.  Some of these aircraft are not even equipped with legacy Ground Prox.  What is a bit puzzling is that some of these same aircraft ARE however fitted with TCAS at a hardware cost approximately three times that of TAWS.  TCAS monitors the airspace around an aircraft for other aircraft equipped with a transponder, independent of air traffic control, and warns pilots of the presence of other transponder-equipped aircraft that may present a threat of mid-air collision.  It’s well documented that as a pilot you have 10 to 100 times the probability of flying into the ground unexpectedly than you do hitting another aircraft in mid-air. That’s a sobering fact.  And, the problem with TCAS (with no GPWS or TAWS) is the possibility that a recommended avoidance maneuver might direct the crew to descend toward terrain below a safe altitude.  Requirements for incorporation of TAWS ground proximity warning mitigate this risk.  TAWS ground proximity warning alerts have priority in the cockpit over TCAS alerts (windshear alerting has the highest priority, if so equipped).”

According to Norm classic GPWS that have provided a last line of defense from a CFIT incident have been available for well over thirty-five years.  Don Bateman, a Canadian-born engineer, developed and is credited with the invention of GPWS. Since 1974, when the US FAA made it a requirement for large aircraft to carry ground prox, there has not been a single passenger fatality in a CFIT crash by a large jet in US airspace. “Universal TAWS with its’ unique Terrain Awareness modes in addition to standard GPWS modes has been available since 2000.  TAWS will provide crews with a warning of terrain ahead of the aircraft as well as classic GPWS warnings.”
 
Universal TAWS was also designed to complement well-known Universal UNS-1 WAAS Flight Management Systems (wFMS).  Integration with the FMS provides an additional unique predictive alerting feature of Universal TAWS, based on knowing where the aircraft will be later in the flight plan.   Universal TAWS uses aircraft inputs such as position, attitude, air speed and glideslope, along with internal terrain and airport databases to predict a potential conflict between the aircraft's future flight path and terrain.  The resulting unprecedented look-ahead capability can provide warnings and alerts well in advance of potential hazards, allowing time for the pilot to make the necessary maneuvers or data corrections for terrain avoidance.  UNS-1 FMS also supports true track navigation in Northern Domestic Airspace and has gravel runways loaded in the navigation database. The Equal Time Point/Point of No Return pages of UNS-1 specifically benefits northern Canada remote ops.

Norm is far from alone when it comes to options and qualified opinions related to CFIT incidents and their prevention. According to Frank Dennis – Field Aviation Sales Representative, Avionics Sales and Service - many affordable options exist for smaller operators big and small who are looking to improve safety. “They can do so by providing their flight crews with additional tools in the cockpit. As an example Garmin’s new GTN Series of standalone GPS units and GPS/Nav/Com units come standard with high-resolution terrain graphics and WAAS capabilities. Full TAWS-B capability is available as an option and graphical weather and traffic upgrades are available. This allows operators to determine what features are most important to their specific operations and add other features as budget and other operational considerations allow.”

Dennis also points to Avidyne’s TAS 600 Traffic Advisory System series that covers a wide range of aircraft.  They are compatible with many different manufactures displays, meaning operators may not need to upgrade cockpit displays to add this capability. And as Dennis notes, these systems can be purchased for under $30,000.00 installed, depending on what add-ons (traffic, weather, etc.) operators choose to purchase.  “With mandatory TAWS regulations coming into force soon, now is an excellent time for operators to research what options are available to them” he adds.

Collins Radio, now Rockwell Collins, has been manufacturing and selling radio equipment since the early 30’s. Rockwell Collins Commercial System products are in a broad spectrum of aircraft, from communication, navigation and surveillance equipment in turbo prop aircraft, to their Pro Line Fusion system used in intercontinental corporate jet aircraft.

According to John Peterson, Director of Avionics Marketing for Rockwell Collins, “We do have cost-effective solutions for making light business/commercial air travel safer in remote areas.  Rockwell Collins offers services and products that can assist pilots and operators in these situations, from training and airborne warning systems, to complete cockpit upgrades that take advantage of the latest technologies.”   

One example that Peterson provides is the Rockwell Collins ALT-1000 (radar altimeter). It measures height above terrain up to 2,500 feet and it is accurate to within 2 feet at the critical low altitudes. The instrument provides a second altitude check for a pilot, by giving absolute altitude from the ground as well as providing information for alerting functions, such as DH.  “It's robust - it is certified for Category II landings” he says.

Rockwell Collins TCAS system is something else to consider in a modern cockpit according to John. “TCAS II works by interrogating the ATC transponders of other nearby aircraft, to determine and display their altitudes, ranges and relative positions. If necessary, they compute and display a recommended vertical avoidance maneuver to ensure safe separation. Rockwell Collins, in conjunction with Bristow Helicopters, now offers a turn-key package to install and certify TCAS II on Rotary Wing platforms.”
The Rockwell Collins Pro Line 21 avionics suite is no stranger to Canadian skies. It integrates different functions, including TAWS and EVS.  According to Peterson, Pro Line 21 offers cost-effective EVS solutions that can prove valuable during dark hole approaches, dark taxi, and low visibility conditions.
In terms of the future, he points to the Rockwell Collins HGS-3500 (Head-up Guidance System) solution for turboprops and light jets. “This will further improve flight operations by keeping pilots’ eyes forward and outside the aircraft with synthetic vision, EVS and flight guidance cues” says John.
When all is said and done, it is clear that the ability of northern flight operators to provide enhanced and reliable service to their clients and communities with the aid of improved safety and efficiency is readily available. The avionics aids are on the market now can and do make a big difference and more are coming soon. Cost is always a consideration for these operators. As some travellers have reported, a ticket on one these smaller, regional type airlines can easily cost as much if not more as one on the major carriers between hub cities. For those who feel cost is factor, many of the avionics manufacturers will find ways to work with the operators to provide incentives and financing options – for those who qualify. So be totally blunt, not one life should ever be lost again for sake of a few dollars worth of technology and some training. The pending rule change from Transport Canada is simply making the reality of this something more tangible for an invaluable category and area of aviation service and support in Canada.   

Thursday, October 4, 2012

How great things grow . . .


From humble beginnings.


I had the pleasure back in my 20s of being part of a very special and at that time unique aviation experience. Little did I know that the experiences I gained and the tuition it offered would become the skills and background I call on today in many different ways. The Canadian Warplane Heritage Museum (CWH) was in its infancy then and became my second home – as was the case for many like-minded aviation folks. This year marks the 40th Anniversary for what is Canada’s – and for that matter one the worlds – largest collections of flying vintage aircraft. In the years since this group started, it certainly has grown and seen not only its fair share of change, but also survived and bettered itself from incidents that would have closed most operations. The museum we see today is a fine and well developed machine focused on preserving aviation history, being publicly accessible and taking itself out to other aviation locations to broaden its reach. And as it turns 40 it is only fair to look back and see how this impressive organization grew and developed from very simple and humble beginnings. It truly is an “if you build it they will come” scenario.

In the early 1970s, businessmen and friends Dennis Bradley and Alan Ness decided to take their love of aviation to a new level through joint ownership and operation of a high performance aircraft. They thought they wanted a Spitfire. A lead for one in Australia actually turned out to be a Fairey Firefly. Neither of them (or for that matter most of us back then) really knew anything about it. At the 1971 Oshkosh Air Show Dennis learned of a Firefly based at Wadley, Georgia. The owner had intended to turn it into a transcontinental racer but never started.

Dennis and Alan approached John Weir and Peter Matthews to join them as partners in the venture. Travelling to Georgia they found the Firefly sitting in a cornfield. After inspection determined it to be restorable, they purchased it for $10,000. Several weeks later, the Griffon engine was fired up and the Firefly headed towards Toronto. The pilot got as far as Fredericksburg, Virginia, where a hydraulic failure forced him to land with the tail wheel retracted. Dennis and Alan rented a Twin Commanche and flew to Virginia. They were met there by Firefly owner who flew up in his Cessna 310. The Firefly was rendered ferryable and the old owner headed north in it, being followed in formation with Dennis and Alan. The Firefly was equipped with only basic instruments - no compass or radio. The formation encountered poor weather and became separated near the north shore of Lake Ontario. Dennis and Alan landed at the Toronto Island Airport for customs only to discover the Firefly had just arrived ahead of them without communication to the tower. Toronto International Airport was where the restoration was to take place. On starting the Firefly for the short flight there the Kaufmann starter on the engine became unserviceable.  They managed to get running using ropes, tires and a truck borrowed from the airport manager. Once again in flight the Firefly became separated from the group and controllers at Toronto Centre provided radar vectors to the “Nordo” aircraft. They eventually formed up again and were cleared to land.

Restoration work commenced almost immediately and on June 4, 1972 the Fairey Firefly was test flown. At this time all four partners came to the realization that flying a vintage warbird exposed them to certain liabilities. They decided to operate the aircraft through a non-profit corporation and named it "Canadian Warplane Heritage."

By 1973 CWH was calling Mount Hope Airport its home. In March of that year charitable foundation status was obtained and a Chipmunk donation started the expansion of the collection. More aircraft followed, the Harvard and Tiger Moth, followed by the Corsair. The rest as they say is history. One hangar became two. More aircraft and members followed.  Even the devastating fire of 1993 was turned into a positive with the building of the current museum facility – a $12 million dollar purpose designed and build home to one of this countries most valued aviation trusts.

I remember sitting in the original CWH hangar years ago with Dennis and I asked him as we looked around  “did you ever plan on it becoming something like this?” His reply was a simple “no” with a big smile. Funny thing how the right idea can become something incredible and take on a life of its own. 

Monday, October 1, 2012

SMS - Flawed or Fabulous?


The acronym SMS - which stands for safety management systems - has become a standard term in the Canadian aviation vocabulary. Depending upon who you speak with or what aspect of SMS you are covering, it is either a wonderful and great addition to the aviation operational structure or could be laying the groundwork for potential disaster.
What is SMS?
According to the Canadian Council for Aviation and Aerospace (CCAA), SMS is “an integrated set of work practices, beliefs and procedures for monitoring, supporting, and improving the quality of safety and human performance in an organization. SMS assists organizations in recognizing the potential for errors, and establishes robust defenses to prevent them from causing injury or accident.” What the CCAA correctly identify is that SMS is about people and a companywide commitment is key they say to the successful SMS implementation.  It's only through the collective efforts of all members of an organization that SMS will successfully manage human error and safety programs effectively. What SMS is supposed to do is shift the focus from managing safety to as the CCAA best put it,  “managing safely”.
In Transport Canada's (TC) vision, SMS will be implemented in all regulated civil aviation organizations in this country by the year 2015. The TC website states “today the majority of Canada's aviation industry operates with SMS policies, processes, procedures and systems in place, including Canada's largest passenger air carriers. In fact, SMS covers more than 90% of passenger kilometers.” As of October 2011 TC stated that for the remainder the industry (that is those who do not have an SMS in place yet), SMS will be implemented over a three-year phased in period. This will begin after the SMS regulations for the sectors not currently under the system come into force. For small operators, TC has adjusted its SMS implementation schedule to provide additional time to refine procedures training and guidance material based on inspector and industry feedback.
SMS is supposed to help companies identify safety risks before they become bigger problems. As we move forward SMS is becoming the global standard. Canada has led the world and ICAO have taken this country's lead and helped define it as a process and system to be implemented around the world. In November of last year the Air Line Pilots Association International (ALPA) - the world's largest nongovernment aviation safety organization - stated “SMS programs ensure continuing safety bike and binding the appropriate levels of incentive for front-line employee reporting, internal auditing and regulatory oversight.” According to the association's president, Capt. Dan Adamus, “Canada is a world leader in adopting SMS programs in its Marine rail and aviation industries and ALPA is proud to be part of that effort.”
Critics are cautious about being identified – in fear for their jobs or recrimination. But that said they do make some good points. One transport Canada manager stated to me privately that while SMS is a great tool, it should not be the only tool in the box. It should be one of the series designed to promote and assist in safe aircraft operations. And SMS should not be implemented in a manner to replaces the human oversight that many operators require. As another person from TC said, for those who operate properly and in a conscientious manner SMS will be the right tool to help them manage and operate their businesses properly. However for those who with a mindset or predisposition to operate outside of the rules, SMS could allow such folks to get away with things that they otherwise would not.
According to the online site fairwhistleblower.ca (FAIR), when implemented properly such systems (SMS) can ensure greater consistency and reliability of operations. However according to FAIR, the experience of many is that these systems have often not lived up to their promise. They cite sloppily implemented and/or aggressively profit driven organizational cultures that come into conflict with the fundamental aim or intention of the system. As a case in point they quote the 2008 incident when the US air carrier Southwest Airlines was found to have skimped on vital airframe inspections that were designed to detect metal fatigue. Dozens of uninspected and affected airplanes flew in some cases over a period of months. It was only when the FAA inspectors went “public” with the information that they had found cracks in these aircraft that the problems then got fixed. FAIR point out that SMS is often characterized as letting the fox guard the hen house. “Industry insiders such as pilots mechanics inspectors air-traffic controllers have all been especially vocal about what they see as a progressive degradation of air safety in Canada” the group says.
In reality SMS is here and not going away anytime soon. You can choose to work with the process, learn how to operate properly within it, and make it part of your corporate culture in a positive way, or you can fight an uphill battle. As the SMS system itself shows, the process is one built upon refinement and change over time. Experience allows input and refinement based on both positive and negative experiences.

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Our throw away society . . .


But the aviation industry is not as bad as the consumer media would have us believe!


Our humidifier was not working. The repairman advised it was going to cost just a few dollars shy of what the whole unit was new. So my decision - repair or replace? The unit is only four years old, properly maintained and was the best you could buy at the time. Needless to say I was not amused.


But this is just the tip of a bigger issue. They just don’t build things like they used to. Take the “white goods” you have at home - fridge, stove, washer and dryer, washing machine and even microwave. Retailers say the days of buying appliances for 15 or 20 years are gone. The average warranty is one year and according to experts you can expect six years to maybe eight before you either fix or throw away – because once again the cost to repair vs. replace makes it attractive to do so.

We have a throw away mentality. Our friends who are into environmentally responsible will tell us, we are our own worst enemies. Our landfills are rapidly getting full with things that do not break down. And we continue to add to the pile.

What about the aviation industry? Are we really all that bad for the environment? After some review and discussions the conclusion I came to was no. Emissions arguments aside, we are better members of society than say the auto industry or “white goods” manufacturers in my view. 

An aircraft comes from the factory with the ability to improve, enhance and develop many times and in many ways over the life of the airframe. From the avionics suite, the entertainment components, the galley, and even the engine and related systems, every part can to be maintained and up rated. That adds life and usability to the whole aircraft increases use over a longer period of time – vs. replacing and scarpping.

Commercial aircraft manufacturers are becoming increasingly responsible for the “cradle to grave” aspect of an aircraft. They build them with a view to how the aircraft can or will be taken apart and disposed of when it is finished its job. According to numbers from IATA, some 12,000 commercial aircraft are on the order books to be delivered by the year 2020. At the same time the Aircraft Fleet Recycling Association (AFRA) tells us that 12,000 aircraft could be scrapped in the next 20 years. By the year 2016, AFRA should have the ability to recycle 90% of an aircraft. That number currently stands in the 80% to 85% at most which is up from less than 50% of a few years ago. Even the airlines - Air France in particular - are increasingly taking an ownership position in the disposal of their retired aircraft.  They now take it upon themselves to play a role in the dismantling and parting out of the components once it is out of service.

 

The hardest parts of an aircraft to recycle come from the cabin – mostly the interior fit and finish. Experts feel the latest aircraft will not necessarily be any easier to recycle.  The reasons lie in the materials being used.  Newer aircraft are lighter and more fuel-efficient due in part to carbon fiber and composite materials. While disposal of these products is far less energy intensive - hence less expensive to recycle - the facilities that are able to do such at present are few and far between. It will be a number of years before a Boeing 787 hits the scrapyard and accordingly one would expect that by that time, the processes and systems to recycle carbon fiber will be as common as those we have today for aluminum.

Some small operators do exist today to help. Take Toronto based Electronics Recycling Services (ERS). They have a line of machines that runs over 3200 linear feet and will take old avionics, cabin entertainment systems and components and reduce it to reusable materials. The handle plastics recovery (granulation of mix materials that are not recoverable via other methods for reuse as fillers for Plastic Lumber Manufacturing Line), an Electrostatic Separation to recover Copper, Lead, Zinc, and Tin plus shredding of all types of electronics, ferrous material separation and aluminum separation can be accomplished by them. They boast that over 90% of what comes in ends up reused in some other manufacturing. While they are growing, they are still a small part of the scrapping system today. More like them need to come along – and soon.

Aircraft have a usable life of 25 to 30 years on average. Automobiles get replaced every 5 to 10 years. There are far fewer airplanes than there are cars, fridges, washing machines and such going to the scrapyards. And with 90% of the aircraft being recycled, aviation is not a bad member of society. We certainly do not contribute anywhere near the amount of others to the ongoing “garbage” pile from humanity.